TONIGHT… Everyone’s favorite show is back and ready to bring the summer heat. We asked the ultimate question: Which athlete would win Love Island?

Let’s be real. Not every champion is cut out for the firepit. Sure, dominating on the court is a big flex, but surviving a recoupling or Casa Amor? Now, that’s a whole different ball game.

Travis Kelce: NFL Tight-End, Full-Time Heartthrob

I mean, he’s built for the Love Island Villa. He’s tall, he’s tatted, and funny. What more could you ask for? Whether he was making breakfast for the girls, lifting weights at the gym, or having deep chats by the fire pit, he would win our hearts. He would bring the fun into the villa.

Odds to win: 10/10

Alex Morgan: Everyone’s Girl Crush

Associated Press Photo / Marcio Jose Sanchez

Female soccer star or reality TV star? She’s the ultimate cool girl. Alex Morgan would walk into the villa with all the confidence needed and become the girl every islander would want to couple up with. She’s athletic, smart, and stunning! She would dominate in challenges and stay unbothered by the drama. Icon behavior.

Odds to Win: 9.2/10

Aaron Judge: America’s Sweetheart

MLB players on reality TV just somehow make sense. “He’s definitely my type on paper” is what most islanders would say about Aaron. Beyond the looks, he is most certainly a softie. He gives the vibes that he would pair up with one girl and stay loyal throughout the season. Yes, even through Casa Amor. Winning everyone’s hearts and making it look good.

Odds to win: 8.5/10

Simone Biles: The Main Character

Simone Biles wouldn’t just survive on the villa. She would thrive. She’s the type that would walk in, and jaws would drop. Hair slicked, untouchable energy, and a great bikini, her entrance would break the internet. She’s the islander who would not play any games (except the challenges) and shut down any nonsense with a simple look. She would bring the realness into the villa.

Odds to Win: 9/10

Charles Leclerc: Mr. Smooth Operator

The Ferrari F1 driver would come in hot! He would be the perfect bombshell coming in, ready to step on anyone’s toes (if necessary). He gives off just enough mysterious energy to make all the girls spiral, trying to crack his shell. Charles would bring fashion to the villa, making every dramatic walk-up look like a Monaco runway.

Odds to Win: 8/10

Caitlin Clark: Here to Shoot Her Shot

Caitlin would be the girl who wouldn’t have to try in the villa. She would bring the chill vibes and a touch of sarcasm that keeps the islanders on their toes. But don’t be fooled; she definitely would know how to play the game. She’s sharp, confident, and knows exactly what she brings to the table and exactly what she wants. She might start as “the girl who’s too chill to play the game,” but by Week 5, she’s everyone’s winner pick.

Odds to Win: 7.5/10

This cast would be an instant classic. With the right amount of competitiveness, banter, and drama, the athletes would redefine life in the villa.

Which athletes would you want to see on Love Island?

Top Athletes Who Could Dominate the Love Island Villa